Trump's false claim that Obama 'never even tried to fix' police brutality
"President Obama and Vice President Biden never even tried to fix this during their eight-year period. The reason they didn't try is because they had no idea how to do it." - President Trump, in remarks on the signing of an executive order on policing, June 16, 2020
OK, we know that President Donald Trump detests his predecessor, Barack Obama.
Just in recent months, while battling the coronavirus pandemic, Trump has falsely accused Obama of mishandling the swine flu epidemic; leaving "empty" the Strategic National Stockpile, a repository of emergency medicines and supplies; and providing "old tests" for a disease that had not even emerged yet.
Now, faced with another crisis - mass protests against police brutality in the wake of the death of George Floyd - the president knocked Obama again. Before signing an executive order that seeks to provide incentives for police departments to increase training on the use of force, Trump asserted that Obama and his vice president "never even tried to fix this during their eight-year period."
Seriously, this was a claim made by the president.
Obama faced his own uproar over police brutality in 2014, after the shooting death of an unarmed black man, Michael Brown, by a white police officer in Ferguson, Mo. Indeed, one of his critics at the time was none other than then-private citizen Trump.
Obama took a number of steps in response, in particular issuing an executive order that created a task force on "21st century policing." The group was asked to hold public hearings and meet with officials and nongovernmental groups to develop recommendations.
The task force was co-chaired by Charles Ramsey, commissioner of the Philadelphia Police Department, and Laurie Robinson, a George Mason University professor who had twice served as assistant attorney general for the Office of Justice Programs, the research, statistics and criminal justice assistance arm of the Justice Department.
A final 115-page report was delivered in May 2015 with dozens of recommendations, such as seeking more data on police-involved shootings, "whether fatal or nonfatal, as well as any in-custody death"; improved assessments of community attitudes toward police; and the removal of incentives on police practices such as a predetermined number of tickets, citations, arrests or summonses.
Some of the recommendations have eerie echoes of recent events: "Law enforcement agencies should create policies and procedures for policing mass demonstrations that employ a continuum of managed tactical resources that are designed to minimize the appearance of a military operation and avoid using provocative tactics and equipment that undermine civilian trust."
Indeed, elements of Trump's executive order could have been lifted from the Obama-era report. Trump called on the Justice Department to encourage more training of police officers with "respect to encounters with individuals suffering from impaired mental health, homelessness, and addiction." The Obama report had several recommendations along those lines, including making "Crisis Intervention Training (CIT) a part of both basic recruit and in-service officer training."
Of course, recommendations are only a start - just as signing an executive order does not mean policy is being implemented. The Obama task force issued an implementation guide for police departments and a year later reported that 15 police departments had agreed to an action plan to implement the recommendations.
That might seem like a drop in the bucket, but the report was closely studied by other police departments. "According to a survey of forty-seven of the largest law enforcement agencies in the United States from 2015 to 2017 conducted by the Major Cities Chiefs Association (MCCA) and the National Police Foundation, 39% of the departments changed their use of force policies and revised their training to incorporate de-escalation and beef up scenario-based training approaches. Significantly, officer-involved shootings during this period dropped by 21% in the agencies surveyed," Robinson said in a recent assessment of police reforms since Ferguson.
Obama took other steps as well. In May 2015, on the recommendation of a White House working group established that January, he banned federal transfers of certain types of military-style gear to local police departments, including tracked armored vehicles, bayonets, grenade launchers, ammunition of .50-caliber or higher, and some types of camouflage uniforms.
Trump in 2017 rescinded that executive order.
Obama's Justice Department also aggressively pursued consent decrees, approved by courts, in which police departments agreed to a road map of changes and reforms. Trump's first attorney general, Jeff Sessions, ordered a review of such deals when he came into office and then sharply limited their use and their length on the day he was fired.
Asked about Trump's comments, Nancy G. La Vigne, vice president for justice policy at the Urban Institute, responded: "Untrue. There actually were extensive efforts to reform policing that were evidence-based and informed by leading experts in the field. This includes the Task Force on 21st Century Policing and the National Initiative in Building Community Trust and Justice," she said in an email. "Further, DOJ under AG Eric Holder pursued consent decrees and pattern and practice investigations with vigor - two strategies that this administration has abandoned."
When we asked the White House to provide a factual basis for Trump's claim that Obama didn't try to fix the issue, we received a response that suggested the complaint was more about how Obama tackled the problem.
"This President is about action and this executive order will do more than any previous administration on police reform," a senior administration official said. "This executive order has both law enforcement and victims' families' buy-in. This is meaningful action for victims and their families, but we won't solve this problem by demonizing police. We must work together with them, and this executive order will help to resolve some of the issues of injustices we see across the country."
The official added that "the Trump administration rolled back the practice of consent decrees because they were not effective."
This is one of those needlessly false claims made by Trump. He could have offered a reasoned critique of the actions taken by Obama, given that his administration has rolled back or limited some of the actions that Obama instituted in response to Ferguson. Instead, Trump asserted, without any basis, that Obama and Biden "never even tried to fix this during their eight-year period."
Clearly, Obama did try - whatever one concludes about the results. Instituting changes in law enforcement and police training takes years of sustained effort and conscientious follow-through. Trump will find that simply signing an executive order is only the start of a long process.
In the meantime, he earns Four Pinocchios.