Thai coup won't restore GDP growth, confidence: Moody's
May 27, 2014 00:00
By THE NATION
THE MILITARY COUP will neither restore investor confidence in Thailand nor help its economy to avoid a cut in its growth forecast this year of 2-3 percentage points from its pre-crisis 4.5 per cent if the political impasse persists for the rest of the yea
Moody’s said in its updated “Credit Outlook” publication yesterday that last Thursday, the Army suspended the Constitution and ousted the government, two days after declaring martial law.
Moody’s currently assigns Thailand a sovereign rating of “Baa1”, with “stable” outlook. However, the coup is credit-negative, underscores the country’s perilous politics and will not restore investor confidence nor ease downward pressure on the gross domestic product, as reflected by real GDP trending far below its potential growth rate this year.
The National Economic and Social Development Board (NESDB) also recently cut its view for full-year 2014 GDP growth to 1.5-2.5 per cent from 3-4 per cent estimated last November, when the anti-government political turmoil first surfaced.
Army chief Prayuth Chan-ocha in a statement said the coup was necessary to forge a way out of the country’s political crisis. The military’s decision to abrogate the 2007 Constitution, which had reaffirmed the country as a democracy with the rights of free speech and assembly, marks the country’s second coup since 2006, when the military ousted then-prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra.
However, because the military lacks electoral legitimacy, it faces the Herculean task of resolving intractable divisions between the anti- and pro-democratic forces.
The period immediately following the 2006 coup was marked by policy drift. Although the country’s economic and financial fundamentals held up relatively well, political turmoil and uncertainty stymied more dynamic development of the economy. Consequently, Thailand’s sovereign credit quality has remained static, as indicated by Moody’s “Baa1” rating both during military rule and since.
First contraction since 2011
The prolonged stand-off between pro- and anti-government forces is taking its toll on the economy. Official data, released on May 19, showed that real first-quarter GDP on a seasonally adjusted basis shrank 2.1 per cent quarter on quarter or 0.6 per cent year on year. This marks Thailand’s first yearly contraction since late 2011, and is a result of consumers and investors holding back on spending because of the political turmoil.
Even if the chaos subsides, there is no assurance that the military government can remove uncertainty from the investment environment. The NESDB in its economic outlook for this month said a decline in Board of Investment applications and approvals since the second half of last year threaten GDP growth.
The administration of Yingluck Shinawatra had formulated a multi-year infrastructure program worth Bt2 trillion, or 15 per cent of GDP, which the Constitutional Court declared invalid in March. Even if that programme were reinstated, public infrastructure expenditure without an increase in private-sector investment may not be able to sustain investment levels sufficient enough to ensure significant economic growth.
The depth of the political divide prompted the Army to take over governing quickly after imposing an ostensibly more limited martial law. The political divide is reflected in repeated court-ordered delays of national elections, the unchanged intention of the main opposition Democrat Party to boycott a future poll, and the unwavering desire of the major anti-government group to dismantle democratic governance.
Since late last year, government bond yields have been immune to the political events, as has the baht, although Thailand’s high international reserves have declined somewhat in the past year.
“Nonetheless, we see the coup as further weighing on Thailand’s economic performance, with the risk that political uncertainty will continue to dim the investment climate and dampen growth performance,” Moody’s said.
The credit profiles of other regional sovereigns have improved and Moody’s upgraded its ratings by multiple notches from 2006-14 – notably China to “Aa3” from “A2”, South Korea to “Aa3” from “A3” and Indonesia and the Philippines to “Baa3” from “B1”.
The coup is also credit-negative for banks because it adds pressure to already weakened investor and consumer confidence and risks stalling loan growth and undermining asset quality.