An Alipay-app on a smartphone screen and Finnair logos at the Helsinki airport, Finland, 27 January 2017. /EPA
An Alipay-app on a smartphone screen and Finnair logos at the Helsinki airport, Finland, 27 January 2017. /EPA

Mobile payment boom raises question: what will die first, cash or passwords?

Tech March 19, 2017 18:15

By Liu Zheng
China Daily
Asia News Network

2,433 Viewed

THE growth in mobile payments will spur the development of China’s digital verification industry.



According to the latest report released by domestic consulting company iResearch, the market scale of China’s third-party mobile payment more than doubled in 2016 compared with the previous year, reaching $5.5 trillion in total.

The number is nearly 50 times larger than the market scale in the US.

Experts attributed the skyrocketing growth of China’s mobile payment to late development, saying the lack of a credit card culture has accelerated the switch from cash to mobile payment and the emergence of third-party payment enterprises and mobile payment platforms have pushed the growth rate further.

But the fast-paced development has also raised security concerns.

Hakan Persson, CEO of Sweden-based Precise Biometrics Inc, a fingerprint authentication solution provider, said the rise in mobile payments increases security and fraud risks.

“As digital payments and e-commerce keep rising, 60 per cent of all transactions will be made through biometric authentication in 2020,” added Persson, citing a report by information company Acuity Research.

Therefore, it’s not surprising that the hardware industry is also growing rapidly.

“The total shipment volume of mobile devices with fingerprint scanners was about 600 million last year, up 100 per cent year-on-year, and the number is expected to reach one billion,” he added.

And the number is projected to hit 2.5 billion units in 2020.

Persson said although fraud in mobile payments with fingerprint scanning is low today, it would increase as the number of users and transactions grow.

Fingerprint sensors ‘vulnerable’

He said that fingerprint sensors are vulnerable to spoofing via fake fingerprint moulds or even fake fingerprints produced using household materials.

“The more something is easy to use, the less security it has,” said Richard Marko, the chief technology officer of ESET, a global anti-virus software provider who works closely with its Chinese partner Version 2 to deliver IT security solutions to the market.

“All of the ‘one-click’ or ‘no-click’ authentication methods can be easily misused,” he said.

He added that people seldom use proper protection on their mobile devices.

“Whenever a software or hardware is designed, apart from making it user friendly, people should realise that something can be malicious or easily mimicked,” he added.

What is the future for mobile payment?

Information company Nielsen Holdings’ latest “Global Connected Commerce” report found that 86 per cent of Chinese respondents said they used some form of digital payment systems to pay for online purchases in the past six months, a number that was far higher than all the 26 surveyed countries’ average of 43 per cent.

The survey polled 13,000 respondents in 26 countries to determine the approach of consumers to e-commerce.

“Chinese consumers have more payment choices for products and services than ever, while digital payment will continue to win over more Chinese consumers due to its convenient nature,” KiKi Fan, managing director of Nielsen China, said.

Meanwhile, new digital verification methods will also hit the market as the technology matures.

Alipay, the mobile payment application produced by Chinese e-commerce conglomerate Alibaba’s financial arm Ant Financial, has introduced new digital payment approaches to the users, allowing its registered customers to process payment via voiceprint or even virtual reality head-mounted goggles.

“Emerging technologies, such as ultra sound or optical solutions, have been developing to feed consumer’s sweet spots, while fingerprint approach won’t be replaced due to its convenience feature,” said Precise Biometrics’ Persson. 

“The new adoption of other biometric modalities will continuously increase and become complementary to fingerprint technology.”

As the third-party payments apps such as Alipay and Tencent Pay or NFC-driven Apple Pay are widely used in China, people can now effortlessly survive a day without cash, making all their payments digitally with a smartphone.

Statistics from China’s central bank, the People’s Bank of China, show that as of the end of last year, the national average of credit cards per person declined to 0.29.

A survey conducted by the Payment & Clearing Association of China (PCAC) also found the surging cashless trend. It said that 47.5 per cent of the country’s payers have tended to choose mobile payment since it is no longer necessary to carry cash or any bank cards.

Will the mobile payments completely take over cash and physical cards and accelerate the cash-free society to become a reality?

“It’s up to our consumers, if they want to use mobile payment, we’ll help digitalise their Master cards and process to purchase in a secure and convenient way,” a spokesman of MasterCard said.

“We’ve used a tokenisation platform, MasterCard Digital Enablement Service – also known as ‘MDES’, to help Samsung, Google and Apple users to make payment transactions,” he added.

The company has also unveiled Masterpass QR, a QR code enabled payment option that lets customers pay for goods and services from their smart-phones, to boost digital payment.

“We would prefer a world without passwords, a world where making payment becomes more convenient and frictionless though an individual’s biometric authentication solutions,” he said. “Eighty-five percent of transactions in the world are still carried using cash. Payment cards and cash have co-existed for many years and so has mobile payment. I don’t think digital payment will take over cash or cards overnight. The adaption process will take time.”

Most view