The Nation



Thaire Life Assurance

2Q14 profit was 9% below our forecast

Thaire Life Assurance Plc (THREL)

2Q14 profit was squeezed by a bigger commission ratio

THREL posted 2Q13 earnings of Bt90m, up 21% YoY but down 19% QoQ. The result was 9% below our forecast, due to a larger commission ratio than expected. 1H14 earnings rose 9% YoY to Bt201m, which represents 45% of our FY14 projection.

Results highlights

Premium revenue rose by 17% YoY and 5% QoQ to Bt374m, led by sales of non-conventional products. Note that THREL's non-conventional premium revenue jumped by 136% YoY and 72% QoQ to Bt124m, while its conventional premium income declined by 7% YoY and 13% QoQ. The firm set provisions of Bt194m for its life policy reserve (loss ratio) in 2Q14, equal to 46.7% of total premiums (flattish YoY but up from 30.4% in 1Q14, due to seasonality). Significantly, its commission ratio rose to 35.9% in the quarter from 33.2% in 1Q14 and from 25.6% in 2Q13. As such, THREL's combined ratio was 70.7%, up from 63.5% in 1Q14 (but down from 72.1% in 2Q13, due to a lower loss ratio).

ROI was 3.4% in 2Q14 (basically flat QoQ) in tandem with trends in the money market and the SET. Investment income was Bt15m, up 26% YoY, due to investment asset expansion and a higher investment gain on the stock market.


We expect THREL to deliver strong YoY net insurance premium revenue growth for 3Q14, led by seasonality (conventional re-insurance clients normally renew or buy new premiums during the second-quarter). Sales of non-conventional products should see good growth through the year.

What's changed?

Our earnings forecasts of Bt450m for FY14 (up 18% YoY) and Bt510m (up 13% YoY) for FY15 stand unchanged.


THREL's long-term earnings outlook is good. There is scope for upside to our profit forecasts from a lower combined ratio and/or greater premium revenue than assumed. However, the prevailing share price of Bt14.70 implies a stretched valuation—our economic value estimate is Bt13.6/share (embedded value of Bt3.41 + VNB of Bt10.23). We maintain our HOLD rating. At the moment, we believe that BLA offers a more favorable risk-reward proposition. We will attend THREL's analyst meeting next week.

Comments conditions

Users are solely responsible for their comments.We reserve the right to remove any comment and revoke posting rights for any reason withou prior notice.