Home > Headlines > Thai PM's controversial interview with Aljazeera TV

  • Print
  • Email

Thai PM's controversial interview with Aljazeera TV

Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej gave an interview to Aljazeera television on Feb 9, 2008. He insisted only one man died in the October 6, 1976.



Thai PM's controversial interview with Aljazeera TV

In this part, he also defended Thaksin Shinawatra's policies on the southern problems, including incidents in Tak Bai and Krue Sae.

Aljazeera tv : Your predecessor, Thaksin Shinawatra, was criticised for a pretty brutal campaign against Muslim fighters in southern Thailand. Many people who were innocent were caught up in that violence. Do you support his policies in southern Thailand?

Samak : Actually, he doesn't mention any policy. The wrong that he committed, somebody says that… ahh… he says that it… ahh… it's not quite so important mandate, and that's all. That is what he mentioned.

A : But if we refer to Tak Bai, the Tak Bai incident, when many young Muslim men were beaten and rounded up and their bodies were stacked into trucks, many of them suffocated and died…

S : Where?

A : At Tak Bai.

S : Tak Bai? Ohh… You have heard about that incident? Did you?

A : Of course, we've seen the footage.

S : Ahh. There's a group of them make a violence there in the south. Thirty-two of them. And they fled to live in the mosque. And then the military asked them to come out. They doesn't come out. So the military must get in. So the mosque is a clean place, that the dirty man, any kind of weapon, cannot get in. But they just going there, so they just killing from outside. So… 32 of them die. And then that is in the Krue Se. And in Tak Bai they just come to make a shouting. To make a shouting and then any kind of thing to bring six people out from jail. So the whole day, this is the time of the, they don't eat anything, they don't eat in the daytime. So, thousands of them just going there around the police station and something like that. So they end up with the… they say that, ok, we'll let them have the preparation to bring them back, the six people, but they don't, they, in the evening time, so they make a roundup (cough) for all those people and put in the truck.

A : Many of the families would suggest that there were very innocent people rounded up there amongst the…

S : Aww, the innocent people. When that type of movement, around that thing, is innocent or not, I have no idea, but those people going fled in the truck, if they strong enough when they standing in the truck, it's ok. But they spent the whole day, doesn't eat, doesn't drink water, doesn't even swallow any kind of thing, because in the month of that thing, so, they just fall on each other. And 78 die, from so many truck, loading, running by… [?] So that's it. It's a tragedy. It happened. Nobody intend to kill them. They die because of their physical. But they has been caught just to get into the barrack. So, so what's wrong with that? What's wrong with that? What is the execution of that? What is it?

A : What is wrong with innocent people dying?

S : What is the incident that had happened? Everybody in the country know what had happened. And seventy… they fall down on each other. And then 78 died.

A : So you're saying they died because they fell on top of each other?

S : Yes. Nobody kill them. Everybody knows it was…

A : Not because they were packed into trucks without enough air?

S : When people get in the truck, in the good shape, and running, actually nobody think they will be like that, but if they people happen not to eat, not to drink, not to swallow, and then somebody fall down the other on the top… So 78 died, out of 1300.

A : Ok. I'd like to go back to 1976 and the Thammasat University protests, where hundreds of students were beaten, shot, lynched and burned. Historians…

S : Yeah, where did you get that report?

A : Historians suggest that you on your radio programme urged mobs of people to turn out and attack the students…

S : How old are you at that time?

(Pause)

S : How old are you?

A : Let me refer to…

S : Do you born yet?

A : Do you deny that…

S : I haven't got any concern. They write some dirty history to me. I brought the case to the court, so many of them, all time to time. The three incident of that time, only one guy died in Sanam Luang, because somebody beat them and burn them by the… by the… by the… by the wire, uh, by the… by the… by the tire. And this only one. Three thousand student is in the Thammasat University. So they were caught there, and then the military would like to bring them out. So they take the shirt, and like this, like that, uh, like the, bring the shirt and put it on [gesturing to tie hands behind back with opened shirt]. Three thousand lying on the ground of Thammasat University football field. So that they bring all the truck to bring them, put in the shirt and put them on, and then going to let them out to the barrack. Then the only way not to let the people being harmed. Three thousand of them. And then they going out there and so many afraid they fled into the jungle, so many go back home. And then, nobody die in Thammasat University. And the student try to go to the barrack… [?] just to bring the… Nobody die, not…

A : Well with all due respect, historians refer to it as one of the worst atrocities in Thailand's history.

S : That is a dirty history. Somebody did it. Somebody write something dirty like that.

A : Well with all due respect, I've actually watched the footage…

S : What the footage?

A : Of that incident…

S : The killing?

A : Yes, I have seen…

S : It's impossible.

A : I have seen people being beaten…

S : Yes, true, in Sanam Luang, yes.

A : …their limp bodies on the ground…

S : Yes, that's true, that is one guy.

A : You're saying one…

S : Yes.

A : Human rights groups would suggest it was dozens of students, possibly in the hundreds.

S : For me, eh, for me, eh, if I am dirty, I am concerned with many thing, I cannot come this far. This dirty history always come. I just have a, a lady like you come from far away, asking this question. Even the Thai, they dare not ask this question to me. If I am a dirty man like that, I cannot get, when I run as the governor of Bangkok, somebody bring this case again. "Oh, a murderer with the blood in the hand cannot run as a governor." I bring the case to the court. So the judge says that, "Khun Samak, we are going to run, eh? Please forgive them, that misunderstanding, just forgive them and withdraw the case and then a good thing to you." So I just think, I agree with the court, with the judge, so I withdraw the case. And when I ran, eh, I got over million vote in Bangkok. Never before. The highest anyone get is 700,000. I got over one million. And then, how about a man, a dirty man like that being elected? The ward is two million something. I got over one million, and the rest, somebody got one hundred, uh, five hundred thousand. And, is not a proof that the people of Bangkok, educated people, four million voters, they come to vote with two million, one million, over a million voted for me, and the rest, chose a small fraction for others.

A : Alright, you are facing corruption charges over your term as Bangkok governor…

S : And then the corruption charge, can they do anything to me yet? So it's a dirty trick that they… [?] I sue the chairman of the two court. So until now the case run for two years. Why two years cannot bring me to the court yet? Not the, the case is not to the court yet. Any case, bring, three years ago, with the putting a garbage, anything. The cost may be 9000 but that last for ten years. But it finish for three years until now. It's nothing wrong with it, but they want to destroy me. Somebody, I call it a dirty hand, a black hand nobody sees, an invisible hand, want to destroy me. Now, you must stay long enough. Even for anywhere in the world, can you, can see that, must I be in jail with this case or not? It's a dirty trick to Samak to put it in.

If a man like I says that, "You, this reporter, you are lousy girl, you kill someone, you are [?]", will you be like that? No. No.

A : Alright, Mr. Prime Minister, thank you for speaking…

S : No, do believe me. Frankly speaking, you must [?] like that. Someone put a dirty [?] on someone. If I'm a dirty man like that, if I'm corruption, why I was elected?

A : Alright, we have to leave it there…

S : Why this party get 233 seats? Why? Why the one who is very clean get 165? Why? Just ask me the question… just answer the question to me.

A : Alright Mr. Prime Minister, we have to leave it there. Thank you for talking to 101 East.

A : Thank you for coming, but please, uh, do some homework. Don't get some information and ask the question. If I am not real, uh, I cannot come this far. Thank you for coming. That's enough.

S : Thank you.


 
Rules and Conditions
1.The Nation reserves the right to delete any inappropriate comments.
2.Our users are not allowed to republicise or use any information except for your own    personal use. And The Nation web team is not responsible for any illegal comments.
 

Post Comment
 
Comment :  
From :  
Code :
   

Other comment
Ed  28/04/2008 15:10  IP: 58.10.231.88

I'm not his fan in any aspect, but I do agree with his point of view towards the medias in many occasions. Many mass medias, especially Thai press are lazy and hardly do their homework. They just create a buzz to sell out of rumours. They frequently ask but hardly listen to the fact. Then only choose to report what they heard that can be linked to their presumption. So Samak and his party will always be bad guys, no matter how well they work, the other party will always be a cleaner & better, no matter how weak and incapable they are. Don't be a victim of your own bias, guys.
Delete  

Sompon  28/02/2008 20:21  IP: 125.24.86.103

Are "inappropriate comments" factual based comments? Or like under the last PM, are the minority supposed to cheer in praise or have their websites and comments deleted?
Delete  

Sunny  27/02/2008 11:01  IP: 125.24.83.117

All the uneducated of Issan and North have elected a joker,with foul mouth to the top seat.Anyway,law of Karma is not too far S.Just wait for the time.
Delete  

not disappointed  27/02/2008 00:21  IP: 125.24.73.17

It's amazing the level of arrogance of this man. He expects people to believe him and not the facts. Getting elected by a large majority doesn't mean prove squat. It doesn't ameliorate guilt nor give truth to lies that is spew from this pigmaster. Democracy doesn't just end with a populist vote and the winner takes all. His evasiveness, disregard of facts, and high ability to fictionalize with his obscene interpretation of history. He remembered that there were 3,000 students but forgot that over 40 of them were extra-judicially murdered.
Delete  

MaxMaximilianMaximus  26/02/2008 22:02  IP: 78.154.96.230

Samak : an ill-mannered, arrogant man with piggy nose, doggy mouth, and buffalo brain.
Delete  

Roberto  25/02/2008 18:35  IP: 58.8.213.102

SAMAK MY MAN.....his English is not too good ........he did however make a point. People who make trouble, get into trouble and sometimes suffer the terrible consequences. This is Life and Death on Planet Earth.
Delete  

Michael  25/02/2008 00:57  IP: 192.100.70.210

The election of Samak is proof that Thailand is not a true democracy. At this point in history, Thailand is not capable of having a true democracy. The ignorant people of Issan, and the North, have elected a clown. Samak, and Thailand, are a joke to the International community. My heart goes out to the many good and decent Thai people. It's unfortunate that HM the king is now an old man. He is the only one who truly loves Thailand, and the Thai people. Your politicians are all self serving. Thailand needs a benevolent dictator, like Singapore, until the peole are educated in the ways of democracy. Military coups are not good things; however, a new coup would be better than a Samak/Thaksin government. It's just a matter of weeks until PAD calls out its foot soldiers. Histroy wil record PAD and its supporters as true patriots...like the true Thai patriots who resisted the Japanese in WWII.
Delete  

Here to stay because I love it  24/02/2008 06:18  IP: 222.123.210.186

People need to stop being so full of hate & jealousy. The Thai people have spoken. The "old" power click "democrats" just can't accept what the people want. I believe Samak is truthful to his innocence all these "old" school "dems" keep throwing at him. LET THE COUNTRY HAVE A CHANCE TO PROSPER. Take a chill pill folks.
Delete  

bizuh  23/02/2008 22:10  IP: 117.47.47.88

Please pinch me! wake me up so this nightmare can stop.I was dreaming that a bad guy name Thaksin was runing the country,getting rich,killing people,then came the army,lead by somber and dictatorials character,finely the devil showed up,very mean and completely stupid with short white hair..What happen to Thailand?????
Delete  

Deng youngyuth  23/02/2008 09:16  IP: 125.27.30.188

What Thais have done to themselves . This man is not capable of running a country ..you need leadership,integerity,Honour....not to mention an education . he should have been left in the kitchen cooking, not on the international stage ...I am embarassed. Is this the best Thailand has?..why do we do it to ourselves? ...the answer is pure greed and corruption . Back to the past for Thailand ..
Delete  

Mark  22/02/2008 12:08  IP: 58.137.121.130

The interview should have been done in Thai and not in English, it would have been much more interesting. The problem in Thailand is that people have a very short memory. They forget easily what happened one year ago, so how could they remember what happened 30 years ago? Thai politicians don’t want the folk to become educated because they would lose their power and their source of income for them, their family and friends. As long as the folk is uneducated, politicians can keep messing around with Thailand!
Delete  

David Brooks  21/02/2008 15:19  IP: 161.200.255.162

Thank you Nation for publishing this transcript. Let's forward it to all Thai people--how about a Thai translation for non-English language readers. Let's have this government show all it's opinions publicly like this so we all can stop listening to absurdly unprofessional people pretending to have honor and credibility. Please keep publishing transcripts!
Delete  

Watchman from UN  21/02/2008 10:42  IP: 203.156.86.116

Even my maid from Issan can talk better English then this stupid Samak the cook. This man is a disgrace to my adopted country. God save Thailand .
Delete  

Sick No MORE  20/02/2008 23:51  IP: 155.85.58.253

A student at Grade-8 probably speaks better English than this dumbzhit. So..oh stupid. This animal bragged that he was graduated from Thammasat too. No brain left for good things. All filled up with EVILS. Satan Sunt-AVEJI.
Delete  

Jason  20/02/2008 23:42  IP: 63.167.255.154

It seems like Thailand has taken a step backwards. Samak is a phony puppet for Thaksin. A man who sees only black and white and his truth is the only possible truth. I pray and hope for peace in the South, however, I think peace is impossible now. At least in the precievable future with Samak in power.
Delete  

Jennifer  20/02/2008 21:38  IP: 58.8.213.189

AMAZING!! I'm speechless!!
Delete  

Typical Thai Folk  20/02/2008 21:12  IP: 124.121.85.149

What a smart ..... PM.!!!!. I am very embarrassed by this joker who represents Thailand. He has no sense of honor or integrity.
Delete  

Seapie  20/02/2008 18:05  IP: 134.146.9.27

I can't wait to see the end of this.
Delete  

Uncitizen 1  20/02/2008 17:50  IP: 203.156.86.116

What school did this Scum Bag Isarn Dog go to. How could he talk like this about human lives that were innocent. Hope that the Lord Buddha will punish him for lying through his nose .IDIOT
Delete  

george  20/02/2008 17:44  IP: 203.113.77.36

This is a great shame on Thailand to have such a PM who is better in cooking than in politics. Maybe he should make a test about his abilities and his view of realities ? Why the Thais prefer people like him to "govern" the country ??? It is not understandable.
Delete  

valerie  20/02/2008 16:06  IP: 143.239.7.2

That interview was really awful. I Can't believe he could so an interview that showed thailand in that light. The world sees interviews such as that. He should know better to dismiss deaths of people
Delete  

khun shumpong , narathiwat  20/02/2008 15:24  IP: 60.50.176.62

samak is a arrogant and piece of shit. just another of thaksin proxy and dog. scum bag
Delete  

monk  20/02/2008 14:55  IP: 202.86.188.220

Are Your Prime Minister Drunk when he was given interview at the Aljazeera TV?Or he dosen't have much time to do some homework before the interview? Please be concerned that his says reflects Thailand in the international image.
Delete  

luukkrung  20/02/2008 14:49  IP: 58.8.194.62

It just says it all. He is a disgrace to Thailand with absolutely no genuine empathy for fellow humans at all. But at least the one positive side of the TRT/PPP dynasty is that whilst the politicians look after their own wallets first and foremost, at least they are throwing scraps of hope in terms of handouts, to the vast numbers of Thais living close to the poverty line. Now, if only normal Thai kids were taught an authentic history of their country and actually taught to question and challenge their past, then history wouldn't be repeating itself so horrifyingly often and Thailand might actually get the politicians it actually needs... people with genuine compassion and a sense of conviction.
Delete  

Smith  20/02/2008 12:49  IP: 71.35.166.41

Rude...Arrogant...Uneducated....liar.... What an embarrassment!
Delete  

Matt  20/02/2008 12:19  IP: 125.27.41.220

What a rude arrogant man Samak is. He really believes that foreigners like to bury their heads in the sand like Thai people when it comes to dirty politics. After seeing the interview I reckon we would have been better off with Thaksin, instead of lying he would have just shown her the red card.
Delete  

Advertisement


Search Search

Privacy Policy (c) 2007 www.nationmultimedia.com Thailand
1854 Bangna-Trat Road, Bangna, Bangkok 10260 Thailand.
Tel 66-2-338-3000(Call Center), 66-2-338-3333, Fax 66-2-338-3334
Contact us: Nation Internet
File attachment not accepted!